Medieval Manuscripts in Cambridge Libraries

A catalogue of Western manuscripts and papyri at Cambridge University Library, the Fitzwilliam Museum and selected Cambridge colleges

Cambridge, University Library, MS Kk.5.19

Diktyon no.: 12207

Contents

Introduction: This paper manuscript dating from the 15th century comprises a copy of Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War and three prefixed pieces concerning the work and life of the Athenian historian. The text of the History ends with an anonymous epigram in elegiac verses taken from the Palatine Anthology. The scribe of the manuscript has been identified as Demetrios Angelos, a Byzantine humanist and physician in the hospital of the Xenon of the Kral, in Constantinople. Angelos was among those scholars who chose to remain in the city following its capture by the Turks in May 1453 and thus did not take part in the important waves of migration to Italy. He is known to have purchased, gathered or copied numerous manuscripts and is thought to have been active from the second quarter of the 15th century as a pupil of Johannes Argyropulus (1416-1486) until 1476. The approximately thirty works he copied not only cover medicine and philosophy, but also history, in which he showed a profound interest. He left annotations in other manuscripts of Thucydides such as Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, grec 1636 and is suspected by some scholars to have owned and studied Vatican City, Bibliotheca Apostolica Vaticana, Ottobonianus gr. 211 , which is, textually speaking, very closely related to Kk.5.19. Another manuscript of Thucydides, Florence, Biblioteca Medicea Laurenziana, Plut. 69.16 was also copied by Demetrios Angelos. It actually sheds some light on several aspects of the Cambridge manuscript: on the first leaf of the Florentine one, Angelos left a note in which he confesses that he finds Thucydides’ work difficult to understand. That detail may explain why, in the Cambridge manuscript, he felt the need to add in the lower margin two sketches depicting descriptive passages of the text which he might have found hard to picture (ff. 57v, 77r). The first sketch in the Cambridge manuscript, on f. 57v, representing the Phaleric Walls, which used to join the city of Athens and the harbour of Phalerum, has a counterpart on f. 57r of the Florence manuscript. The second sketch however, illustrating the fortifications of the city of Plataea, is only present in the Cambridge manuscript (f. 77r). This manuscript also counts among the several witnesses of our copyist’s taste for one specific epigram of the Palatine Anthology about Thucydides (Anthologia Palatina ix, 583). Although he is not the only one to have made use of that epigram as a refined way to conclude the work of the Athenian historian, it seems to occupy a great importance in his copies. Indeed, he not only inscribed the poem in red-ink letters in our manuscript, but also copied it five times successively at the end of the Florence manuscript. He even added his own corrections to the epigram in the aforementioned BnF grec 1636, and, in some of his own copies of Galen’s works, he transformed the content, regardless of the metre, in order to adapt the epigram to the famous physician and the subject of medicine (see: Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, grec 2154 and Vatican City, Bibliotheca Apostolica Vaticana, Urbinas gr. 67 ).

Language(s): Greek

1. ff. 1r-5v
Dionysius, of Halicarnassus, On the Characteristics of Thucydides’ Style (Second Letter to Ammaeus) De Thucydidis idiomatibus (epistula ad Ammaeum)
Rubric: f. 1r Διονισίου Ἀλικαρνασσέως περὶ τῶν Θουκυδίδου συγγραφ⟨έως ἰδιωμάτων⟩
Incipit: f. 1r Διονύσιος Ἀμμαίω τῷ φιλτάτῷ χαίρειν· ἐγὼ μὲν ὑπελάμβαν⟨ο⟩ν ἀρκούντως δεδηλωκέναι τὸν Θουκυδίδου χαρακτῆρα
Explicit: f. 5v ἔχεις ὦ φίλε Ἀμμαῖε τὰ παρατηρήματα καθ’ ἕκαστον αὐτῶν, ἐκ τῆς κοινῆς ἐξητασμένα πραγματείας ὡς ἐπεζήτεις

TLG 0081.011

2. ff. 5v-8v
Marcellinus, Life of Thucydides (defective at the beginning, starts at paragraph 34) Vita Thucydidis
Rubric: f. 5v Μαρκελίνου εἰς Θουκυδίδην τὸν συγγραφέα
Incipit: || f. 5v Λέγεται τὸν Θουκυδίδην παύσασθαι τὸν βίον, ὑπερ τὰ πεντήκοντα ἔτη μὴ πληρώσαντα τῆς συγγραφῆς τὴν προθεσμίαν
Explicit: f. 8v τὴν πραγματείαν αὐτοῦ, οἱ μὲν κατέτεμον εἰς ιγʹ ἱστορίας· ἄλλοι δὲ ἄλλως· οἱ δὲ ἡ πλείους, εἰς ηʹ· ὡς καὶ ὁ Ἀσκληπιός ἐπέκρινεν

The same portion of the text is contained in Oxford, Bodleian Library, Can. gr. 48, ff. 374v-378r, Vatican City, Bibliotheca Apostolica Vaticana, Urb. gr. 92 , ff. 265r-267v and Paris, Bibliothèque nationale de France, grec 1736 , ff. 354r-357v.

TLG 2585.001

3. ff. 8v-10r
Anonymous Life of Thucydides Vita anonyma Thucydidis
Rubric: f. 8v Θουκυδίδου βίος
Incipit: f. 8v Θουκυδίδης Ἀθηναῖος, Ὀλόρου ἦν παίς· Θράκιον δὲ αὐτῶ τὸ γένος
Explicit: f. 10r στήλη τις ἀνέστηκεν ἐν τῆ κοίλη, τοῦτο ἔχουσα ἐπίγραμμα· Θουκυδίδης Ὀλόρου Ἁλιμούσιος ἐνθάδε κεῖται
4. ff. 10r-309r
Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War Historia belli Peloponnesiaci
Incipit: f. 10r Θουκυδίδης Ἀθηναῖος ξυνέγραψε τὸν πόλεμον τῶν Πελοποννησίων καὶ Ἀθηναίων
Explicit: f. 309r ἀφικόμενος πρῶτον ἐς Ἔφεσον θυσίαν ἐποιήσατο τῆ Ἀρτέμιδι, ὅταν ὁ μετὰ τοῦτο τὸ θέρος χειμὼν τελευτήση, ἓν καὶ εἰκοστὸν ἔτος πληροῦται

TLG 0003.001

4.1. ff. 10r-52v
Historiae Liber I
Rubric: f. 10r Θουκυδίδου συγγραφῆς πρώτον
4.2. ff. 53r-88r
Historiae Liber IΙ
Rubric: f. 53r Θουκυδίδου συγγραφῆς δεύτερον
4.3. ff. 88r-125r
Historiae Liber IΙI
Rubric: f. 88r Θουκυδίδου συγγραφῆς τρίτον
4.4. ff. 125r-170r
Historiae Liber IV
Rubric: f. 125r Θουκυδίδου συγγραφῆς τέτταρτον
4.5. ff. 170r-202v
Historiae Liber V
Rubric: f. 170r Θουκυδίδου συγγραφῆς εον
4.6. ff. 202v-239v
Historiae Liber VI
Rubric: f. 202v Θουκυδίδου συγγραφῆς ϛον
4.7. ff. 239v-272v
Historiae Liber VII
Rubric: f. 239v Θουκυδίδου συγγραφῆς ζον
4.8. ff. 272v-309r
Historiae Liber VIII
Rubric: f. 272v Θουκυδίδου συγγραφῆς ηον
5. f. 309r
Anonymous Epigram on Thucydides (Anthologia Palatina, Book ix, 583)
Incipit: f. 309r ὦ φίλος· εἰ σοφὸς εἶ, λάβε μ'ἐς χέρας. εἰ δὲ πέφυκας νῆις μουσάων, ῥίψον ἅ μὴ νοέεις· εἰμὶ γὰρ οὐ πάντεσσι βατός· παῦροι δ'ἀγάσαντο Θουκυδίδην Ὀλόρου, καὶ κεκροπίδην τὸ γένος

The entire text of the epigram is given in red ink

cf. DBBE type 2214

TLG 7000.001

Physical Description

Form: codex
Support: Western paper, folded in folio. Watermarks: scissors ( 30 × 70 mm. ) in the middle of the leaf comparable to Briquet, ciseaux 3668-3685 and Harlfinger, ciseaux 22-64 ; the majority of those examples are dated to the middle of the 15th century (the watermarks Harlfinger, ciseaux 53-64 were produced in Constantinople, the place of activity of the scribe Demetrios Angelos); three mountains and a cross ( 55 × 30 mm. ) in the middle of the leaf comparable to Briquet, monts 11702, 11704-11707 ; the majority of those examples are dated to the middle of the 15th century sole of a shoe ( 45 × 10 mm. ) in the middle of the leaf comparable to Briquet, semelle de soulier 13617-13619 ; the majority of those examples are dated to the middle of the 15th century
Extent: Codex: 9 + 309 + 9 leaves. 275 × 205 mm.
Foliation: [i-ix] + 1-309 + [x-xviii]. Modern foliation in pencil in Arabic numerals in the top right-hand corner, recto.

Collation

The manuscript now consists of 39 quaternions: quires 1-20 and 22-38 are regular quaternions, quire 21 lacks one folio without loss of text, quire 39 two folios.

  • Quires 1-208 ff. 1r-160v
  • Quire 218-1 ff. 161r-167v (one folio cancelled after 166v without loss of text)
  • Quires 22-388 ff. 168r-303v
  • Quire 398-2 ff. 304r-309v

Henry Bradshaw (1831-1886) added notes about the cancelled or lost folios on ff. 166v and 309v.

The manuscript presents three distinct quire signatures which all coincide with one another (all of them are visible on f. 200r):
  • early signatures in brown ink, in Greek numerals from αον (f. 1r) to λθον (f. 304r), on lower corner of the first folio recto of all quires, lost or nearly lost on ff. 25r (δον), 33r (εον), 41r (ϛον), 137r (ιηον), 153r (κον), 161r (καον);
  • early signatures in brown ink, in Roman numerals, mostly lost in trimming but preserved on upper corner of ff. 17r (iii), 200r (xxvi), 208r (xxvii), 248r (xxxii);
  • modern signatures by Henry Bradshaw in pencil οn the lower corner of the first folio recto and a cross on the fifth: quires 1-23 a-i, k-u, x-z (lower-case); quires 24-39 A-I, K-P (upper-case).

Condition

In good condition; folios are yellowed and stained. Some leaves have been torn and repaired at the time of the binding with paper patches, in particular ff. 1 and 309. Humidity and water stains are found throughout the volume, along with brown and orange stains. It contains occasional worm holes (e.g. ff. 62-66)

Layout

ff. 1r-309r: A single column of 26 lines. Written space 205 × 130 mm.

Hand(s)

B. Mondrain has identified the copyist of the manuscript as the Constantinopolitan physician, scribe and scholar Demetrios Angelos active in the 15th century, in a slightly slanting and much ligatured mixed minuscule practised scholar's hand.

Syllabic abbreviations and superscript letter endings are often used and they do not appear only at the end of lines. Breathings are curved and joined to accents; circumflex accent is linkd to the omega. The trema is consistently traced over ypsilon; mute iota is absent.

Demetrios' handwriting is characterized by the beta with an elongated vertical line and ligatures with rho drawn up, traced in a single line and often with small closed loops.

Punctuation used includes the middle and upper point, lower comma, full stop and marginal quotation marks. Deletions are done by strikethrough in red ink (f. 271v)

The handwriting in the rubricated notes, title headings and the final epigram, though presenting the same general characteristics as the one of the main text, is less neat and thicker in appearance. It occasionally seems to have been slightly affected by some blotting effect (e.g. f. 225v). It also regularly appears very faded.

Decoration

Major initials in red ink flourished with vegetative ornaments mark the start of a new text or a new book section of Thucydides’ Histories on ff. 1r, 5v, 8v, 10r, 53r, 88r, 125r, 170r, 202v, 272v. Some title headings of the manuscript are followed by ornamental line fillers drawn in red ink (e.g. ff. 170r, 202v).

Some minor red-ink initials are written within the body of the text along with some rubricated marginal notes.

The manuscript contains two sketches drawn in red ink in the lower margins of ff. 57v and 77r. The first sketch illustrates lines 12 to 16 of f. 57v, corresponding to Histories, Book II, 13, 7. It consists of a map representing the city of Athens on the left, the harbour of Phalerum on the right, and the Phaleric walls joining the two. The scribe also provided the drawing with some informative inscriptions using words directly borrowed from the text of Thucydides. Those include indications of distances in Greek numerals and of the guarded (φυλαττόμενον) and unguarded areas (ἀφύλακτον) on the map. Although the second sketch is found on f. 77r, it illustrates lines 2 to 8 of f. 76v, which corresponds to Histories, Book II, 15, 4. It shows the city walls of Plataea reinforced by a wooden structure made to ensure the protection of the city from the siege of the Lacedaemonians. Although the sketch was originally accompanied by three inscriptions, the one located below the sketch is now lost to trimming. The two other ones are Πλαταία (“Plataea”), which is written within the top circle representing the city of Plataea, and ξύλινον τεῖχος (“wooden wall”), located on the right side of the sketch.

Ornamental chevrons precede the remaining words which the scribe was unable to fit in the last line of a page (e.g. ff. 124r, 125r).

Additions

The notes mark important passages, mostly speeches, with a mention of the type of speech in abbreviated forms: δημηγορία ("public oration”), ἀπόκρισις (“response”) or ἀπολογία (“defence”). Those mentions are followed by one indication of the identity of the speaker and another one on the persons to whom the speech is addressed. Some of the red ink notes are only meant to clarify the meaning of Thucydides’ text. The rubricated notes are on ff.: 19v, 21r, 25r, 28v, 30v, 33r, 34v, 43v, 50v, 56r, 63r, 67r, 70r, 75r, 75v, 76r, 81r, 82r, 90r, 96v, 98r, 100v, 104r, 106v, 127v, 130r, 131v, 143v, 152v, 155r, 156r, 167r, 172v, 186v, 197r, 197v, 198r, 198v, 206r, 208r, 210r, 214r, 215v, 217r, 225v, 228v, 230r, 233r, 243r, 261v, 263r, 267v, 271v, 307v, 309r.

Some notes in Latin have been written by an early modern reader on ff. 17r (‘templum Iunonis’) and 100v (‘pulchra omnino’).

The numbers of the books of Thucydides have been added in the upper margin of rectos in Greek numerals from f. 10r, along with the Arabic numerals standing for the modern chapter divisions in a dark brown ink, e.g. f. 19v, lines 4 and 34, f. 20r, line 17. Richard Porson (1759-1808), Regius Professor of Greek at Cambridge, was allowed to borrow the manuscript in April 1802 and the numbers of the books may have been added by him.

Binding

Bound by Wiseman of Cambridge (first half of 19th century), and signed on lower margin of first marbled endleaf, verso.

Binding in pale brown full leather covering over millboards. Marbled paper endleaves.

The volume is wrapped in a very worn black leather chemise covering the whole binding, save the head and tail of the spine. The name of the author and the classmark are gold-tooled on the spine of the chemise: Kk Thucydides 5 19.

298 × 226 × 73 mm.

History

Origin: The manuscript was copied in Constantinople; by the Byzantine physician and humanist scholar, Demetrios Angelos , in all likelihood between the second quarter of the 15th century and the year 1476, when he is last attested. He is believed to have died in 1479 (cf. Mondrain 2010, p. 299, 304).

Provenance and Acquisition

In the late 15th or early 16th century, the manuscript was certainly brought to Italy by Byzantine émigrés.

At some point, it came into the possession of the Italian humanist and Chancellor of the Republic of Genoa (1514) Benedetto Tagliacarne (1480-1536) , also known as Benedictus Theocrenus, whose mark of ownership (‘Benedicti Theocreni’) is found in the upper margin of f. 1r. It is likely to have been seized along with the rest of his goods by the soldiers of the Holy Roman Empire during the sack of Genoa in 1522.

John Moore (1646-1714) , bishop of Ely: no. 982 in the handwritten supplementary list of Moore's manuscripts, now MS Oo.7.50(2), compiled by Thomas Tanner (1674-1735) after the publication of Bernard, Catalogi librorum manuscriptorum Angliæ et Hiberniæ (c. 1697).

Presented to the University Library in 1715 by George I . The royal bookplate, engraved by John Pine in 1736, is not present.

Additional Information

Record Sources

Description (2019) draws on A catalogue of the Manuscripts preserved in the Library of the University of Cambridge, vol. 3, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1858, p. 690-691 and unpublished description by Clément Malgonne (2015)

Availability

Entry to read in the Library is permitted only on presentation of a valid reader's card. For information on eligibility and admissions procedures, see Joining the Library). For further enquiries, and to confirm the availability of the manuscript, please contact the Special Collections Reading Room.

Bibliography

    Thucydidis De bello Peloponnesiaco libri octo, Poppo, Ernst Friedrich (Leipzig, vol. 1, Gerhard Fleischer, 1843) A catalogue of the manuscripts preserved in the library of the University of Cambridge, (Cambridge, 3, Cambridge University Press, 1858) Thucydidis I, Shilleto, Richard (Cambridge, Deighton, Bell, 1872) Liste des manuscrits de Thucydide Revue des Études Grecques, Dain, A. (46, pp. 20-28, 1933) The Cretan manuscripts of Thucydides The Classical Quarterly, Powell, J.E. (32, 103-108, 1938) Thucydidis Historiae, Alberti, G.B. (Rome, 1, Accademia nazionale dei Lincei, 1972) Cambridge University Library: a history [2], The eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, McKitterick, David (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1986) Jean Argyropoulos, professeur à Constantinople et ses auditeurs médecins, d’Andronic Éparque à Démétrios Angelos Polypleuros nous: Miscellanea für Peter Schreiner zu seinem 60. Geburtstag Byzantinisches Archiv, Mondrain, B. (Munich, 223-250, Saur, 2000) The Greek Manuscripts of John Moore and Etienne Baluze Codices Manuscripti, , (56/57, 29-42, 2006) Démétrios Angelos et la médecine: contribution nouvelle au dossier Storia della tradizione e edizione dei medici greci. Atti del VI Colloquio internazionale, Paris 12-14 aprile 2008 Collectanea, Mondrain, B. (Naples, pp. 293-322, Boudon-Millot, 2010) The library of Richard Porson, Naiditch, P. G. (Philadelphia, Xlibris, 2011) Philologie grecque Annuaire de l'École pratique des Hautes Études (EPHE), Section des sciences historiques et philologiques, Mondrain, B. (146, 55-58, 2015)

Funding of Cataloguing

The Polonsky Foundation

Digital Images

Cambridge Digital Library